Thursday 7 September 2017

When an interviewer asks about your weaknesses ...

For some graduates, it's the toughest question in a job interview:

Tell me, what is your biggest weakness?

How should you answer? And what do potential employers really want to hear?

There was a time when saying you were a perfectionist or a workaholic were the only acceptable answers to the question about professional weaknesses. However, unless you really are a perfectionist or a workaholic (and have supporting evidence), those answers are now considered insincere.

We asked employers in the tax profession to explain what they really want to learn when they ask this question.

Leave rehearsed answers at the door

James Fabijancic, tax graduate recruitment partner in Deloitte's Melbourne office, agrees that rehearsed answers don't cut it anymore.

“We don’t want applicants telling us their weakness is working too hard or being a perfectionist,” he says. “We want to hear real stories and, importantly, how applicants are taking steps to overcome any weakness and make themselves better."

He says the process of working through challenges is more important than what those challenges are, as Deloitte’s culture is “built on working towards outcomes to address clients’ problems”.

Provide solutions, not excuses

Rob Basker, tax partner at Deloitte's Sydney office, says the question is less about weakness and more about how the candidate handles any situation by meeting it with a solution.

“We approach our interviews as exercises in getting to know each other, and to ask questions about situations to test what an individual has done or would do if they were in certain situations,” says Basker. “This way we can see how he/she would approach the matter in question, from thought to finish, to see if they are innovative or if they would create a 'moment that mattered' for our clients and our team.”

A mature response

Other employers, such as Grant Thornton, no longer ask the weakness question, preferring instead to focus on the skills that graduates do have and how they are building on those through professional development.

KPMG, on the other hand, is more specific. They ask candidates about the steps they have taken to address criticism they have received in the course of their work or studies, and whether these steps have resulted in change.

“We would look for a mature response where the candidate would acknowledge the criticism and recognise that people take the effort and time to share feedback to help people improve,” says a KPMG spokesperson.

“If a candidate acknowledged and agreed with the criticism, then seeking out opportunities to undertake similar tasks to demonstrate improved capability and addressing the criticism would reflect positively.

“If a candidate didn’t agree with the criticism received, then we would expect a candidate to undertake a process of validating the criticism with other people as opposed to discarding the criticism as unfounded. Ultimately, a response that reveals the candidate is committed to self-improvement and continued personal development through action would be a good response.”

Again, this suggests that a question of weakness is not about the specific trait you have, but how you handle an issue.

No matter what professional weaknesses you may have, never fear – your self-awareness in the process of acknowledging it and your capacity for self-improvement in how you address it are what employers are really interested in.

Student Membership
Give yourself the edge with free student membership

If you're a tertiary education student, The Tax Institute can help you progress in your career.

Find out about Student Membership.


  1. You would spot the difference between CV and resume here The best compare that I ever seen.

    1. I read many articles but this site very different from others and their contents look attractive like Buy Mens Waist Coat in Pakistan and other articles I read for information.

  2. There was a time when saying that you were a perfectionist or a workaholic were the only acceptable answers to the question about professional weaknesses. He said that help me with my assignment sooner. However, unless you are really a perfectionist or a workaholic (and have supporting evidence), those answers are now considered unintentional.

  3. Many times the interviewer can tell if a person will be right for a job right away but the follow up is very important. Website

  4. This is important when the interviewer has 2 or 3 or 4 people in mind for the job but hasn't really decided who to hire. Click here

  5. College experience does count to an interviewer. Don't give up hope. Also, a lack of paid experience doesn't hinder a job search either. Wood Floor Refinishing NJ

  6. As an interviewer or interviewee? If u mean interviewee then don’t be too critical towards your own weaknesses. Home Damage Restoration

  7. These tips are very useful for us and through these, we can improve our general knowledge about our interview and get success in getting jobs. We should follow these tips and enjoy good jobs. Coursework writing services.

  8. We have the quality centric, and tailored sociology dissertation services, our sociology dissertation editors will ensure your dissertation and give their best.

  9. I enjoyed you blog very much and thanks for sharing. Also, we at our website provide all the solutions to the problems that an SBC Global user can face. Also, we offer setup help if you are a new SBCGlobal user and want to set up your account. For further information, visit our website. SBCGlobal

  10. We will update you about every move or recent changes and new features about Free Minecraft games. Additionally, these games give you the leverage to do anything in this game, that is what makes it fascinating. The curious stories about the game are making it more popular.

  11. World Lanka Food is the best serving grocery store in Japan where you can find all times of Sri Lankan food products.

  12. You should explain you strengths when asked for weaknesses. Heavy Metal Elements Analyzer

  13. Congratulations. Good blog. Keep sharing. I love them Are you also searching for professional nursing paper help? we are the best solution for you.

  14. I just couldn’t leave your website before telling you that I truly enjoyed the top quality info you present to your visitors? Will be back again frequently to check up on new posts.


  15. It was my excitement discovering your site last night. I came here now hoping to find out interesting things. I was not dissatisfied. Your ideas for new methods on this subject were useful and an excellent help to myself.


  16. Such amazing content about interviews helps me a lot in my professional lifeNow it's time to avail
    Hi Vis Traffic Jacketfor more details.

  17. It is full of great information and the author has done an excellent job of presenting the content in a way that is easy to understand. I find the topic to be very interesting and it has helped me gain insight into the subject. I think this post will be very useful for readers who are looking to learn more about the topic. Thanks for the great work!
    Divorcio sin oposición barato en Virginia

  18. this approach can come across as insincere and may not provide the interviewer with the information they are looking for. Instead minesweeper online, it is best to be honest about a real weakness, but also to present it in a way that shows you are aware of it and taking steps to improve magic tiles 3.


  19. When an interviewer asks about your weaknesses, it's essential to strike a balance between honesty and demonstrating self-awareness. Discuss a genuine weakness, but also highlight how you're actively working to improve or mitigate it, showcasing your commitment to personal and professional growth.

    estate planning taxes lawyer

  20. One of my weaknesses is that I am still under development, and I am not yet familiar with all of the features of the 49P2167 - IBM 514-Watts Redundant Hot Swap Power Supply for System x345. However, I am committed to learning more about this power supply so that I can provide the best possible support to my users.

  21. Professionals with extensive expertise of the take my ged online format, content, and scoring guidelines make up our team. They will work closely with you to ensure that your knowledge and abilities are fully and accurately represented on the test. They will cover all subject areas, including Language Arts, Mathematics, Science, and Social Studies.

  22. I like your post! It's exciting to witness the evolution of the Binance killers . With new exchanges like this one on the horizon, users will have more choices and better opportunities to diversify their portfolios

  23. Amazing, Your blogs are really good and informative. I got a lots of useful information in your blogs. However, unless you really are a perfectionist or a workaholic (and have supporting evidence), those answers are now considered insincere lawyer for contract dispute. It is very great and useful to all. Keeps sharing more useful blogs....

  24. I stumbled upon your blog while researching investment strategies, and I'm so glad I did. Your practical advice has already made a positive impact on my approach to building wealth. Wallstreet queen official

  25. Your article is thought-provoking and well-researched. It sheds light on important issues and sparks meaningful conversations binance bitcoin signals